NA deputies and fertiliser manufacturers call for VAT tax benefits

Nov 12th at 07:41
12-11-2024 07:41:58+07:00

NA deputies and fertiliser manufacturers call for VAT tax benefits

National Assembly deputies have been debating whether a 5 per cent VAT tax on fertiliser should be reintroduced.

Loading fertiliser onto a ship at the Đình Vũ Port in Hải Phòng City. — VNA/VNS Photo Quốc Khánh

Opponents of the tax advised the Government to exercise caution, as it may increase fertiliser prices, which would adversely affect millions of farmers across the country.

Supporters, meanwhile, raised concerns over how the tax exemption has been a burden for local fertiliser manufacturers, hurting their competitiveness and creating an unfair playground.

The 5 per cent VAT tax was removed in 2014, which according to local fertiliser manufacturers, has created a situation in which locally made fertilisers suffer unfairly in competition with imports as they could not deduct VAT from their input. It has led to increased production costs. They said their products should also be taxed as it would allow them to benefit from VAT deductions and refunds, which can bring prices down in the domestic market.

Deputy Trịnh Xuân An from Đồng Nai Province said reintroducing the tax will benefit the public, manufacturers and the State.

"For instance, when a company purchases raw materials worth VNĐ80 it costs an additional VNĐ8 in VAT input. If their fertiliser is sold at VNĐ100 without input VAT deductions, they would need to price it at VNĐ108. With a 5 per cent tax, they can deduct VNĐ8, and the price should be VNĐ105. Accounting rules dictate that a 5 per cent tax doesn’t necessarily mean prices rise by 5 per cent."

Deputy Đặng Bích Ngọc from Hòa Bình Province said fertiliser remains so far the largest expense in crop production, amounting to 64 per cent to 68 per cent of the agricultural sector’s total production value.

Fertiliser not being taxed means manufacturers cannot claim VAT tax refunds, even for goods imported as fixed assets required in fertiliser production. This severely handicapped local manufacturers' profit and investment planning, as well as their ability to upgrade to more sustainable technologies.

Meanwhile, imported fertiliser, previously taxed at 5 per cent and now tax-exempt can still reclaim full VAT input, allowing for lower prices.

The fertiliser market which has been struggling with oversupply issues during 2015-20 had seen significant price drops with local manufacturers reporting negative growth and financial difficulties.

Ngọc said allowing local manufacturers to benefit from VAT input refunds will benefit everyone, farmers, manufacturers and the Government while at the same time, reducing Việt Nam's reliance on imports.

She said Việt Nam could learn from China, the world's largest producer and consumer, which imposes an 11 per cent VAT on fertilisers, while offering tax incentives for more environmentally friendly and R&D advanced manufacturers. Similarly, Russia, the world's largest fertiliser exporter, also imposes VAT for the same reasons.

"The current situation favours imports while harming domestic manufacturers. Left alone unchecked, it may reduce the size of Việt Nam's fertiliser industry making the country even more reliant on imports and undermining long-term strategy such as agricultural sustainability," she said.

Deputy Nguyễn Văn Chí from Nghệ An Province said Việt Nam, as an agricultural country, should not allow itself to become overly reliant on foreign fertiliser.

Several Governmental agencies including the Ministry of Industry and Trade and the State Audit have petitioned the Government to reintroduce the tax to balance the playing field for domestic manufacturers. 

Bizhub





NEWS SAME CATEGORY

Over 400 e-commerce platforms register with tax authorities: GDT

As many as 412 e-commerce platforms have registered their tax information with Việt Nam’s tax authorities, according to information on the special portal under the...

Sacombank earns top international security certification for 11th consecutive year

Sacombank has achieved the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) certification at the highest level with version 4.0, marking the 11th consecutive...

Exchange and interest rates forecast to remain stable after US election

Experts believe that Vietnam's economic fundamentals are strong enough to withstand the volatility stemming from the US presidential election results.

SBV’s USD/VNĐ central exchange rate hits all time high

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV)’s central exchange rate of the Vietnamese đồng against the US dollar on Thursday increased by VNĐ25 against the previous day to hit...

E-commerce platforms to pay taxes on behalf of sellers from January 1, 2026: draft

E-commerce platforms may be asked to pay taxes on behalf of sellers from the beginning of 2026, according to a draft amendment to the Law on Tax Management.

State bank to strengthen anti-money laundering efforts with new department

A new Department of Anti-Money Laundering will operate under the State Bank of Việt Nam (SBV) from January 5 next year.

New regulations on mergers, consolidation of credit institutions proposed

The State Bank of Việt Nam (SBV) has proposed new regulations on the mergers and consolidation of credit institutions, to ensure the safety and legitimate rights of...

Rising NPLs under increased pressure

Amid rising non-performing loan ratios, banks face increased pressure to strengthen provisioning and expedite collateral recovery, all while grappling with...

Lowered lending rates to facilitate capital access

The fourth quarter is bringing soaring capital demand for production and housing, calling for timely preferential credit and rate cuts to empower businesses and...

​Vietnam to debut AI tool for e-commerce platform supervision next week

Vietnam will introduce an AI-powered tool next week aimed at overseeing the revenue and business operations of e-commerce platforms, Deputy Prime Minister and...

Bank stocks

Insurance stocks


MOST READ


Back To Top