Delayed tax refunds put firms at risk

Apr 14th at 11:06
14-04-2023 11:06:19+07:00

Delayed tax refunds put firms at risk

Firms are growing frustrated with the excessive delays in tax refunds that have driven them into liquidity problems for years.

The Board for Private Economic Development Research (Board IV) reported that many timber firms had been rendered cash-strapped as they had not received their tax refunds since 2020.

The board is worried that the situation could lead to mass bankruptcies because the total delayed refunds had amounted to trillions of Vietnamese dong.

"Scores of firms would go bankrupt should the problems remain unsolved," said a spokesperson for Board IV.

Hao Hung Company Ltd., a timber exporter, revealed that tax refunds require proof of origin (P/O). However, the firm sometimes finds it impossible to trace its timbers back to the tier-zero sellers (F0) as timber supply involves multiple tiers of sellers.

Without the F0-traceability, its timbers have not been eligible for tax refunds, resulting in a large amount of its capital remaining tied up in the State budget.

The Vietnam Timber and Forest Product Association believed that the tax authority's approach to traceability is problematic as it misplaces the P/O burden onto exporters. The association said it is the tiers of sellers who should bear the responsibility.

The approach also causes a regulatory conflict as the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD) has exempted lawful foresters from registering their timbers with local authorities. Meanwhile, seller traceability requires such registration.

MARD sent Dispatch No.8187 to the Ministry of Finance last year to urge support for timber firms with tax difficulties but the voice has gone unheard since then.

The P/O requirement also has a negative impact on the paper industry as it discourages firms from recycling.

According to the Vietnam Pulp and Paper Association, firms engaging in paper recycling normally find themselves unfit for value-added tax (VAT) refunds because their operation involves the purchase of waste papers that, in most cases, are not traceable.

Companies have requested the General Department of Taxation to relieve them of the P/O burden. The tax authority has agreed to the request but limited VAT refunds to no more than VND100 million (US$4,265) for each firm.

The association believed that VND100 million is such a small amount that it could not act as a financial incentive for recycling.

The situation is not much better for fertiliser firms, which are not entitled to VAT refunds because they have been granted VAT-exempt status since January 1, 2015.

Being exempted from VAT turned out to be more of a bane than a boon for the firms as they were left with no choice but to record their otherwise VAT refunds as production costs.

Higher production costs have driven up fertiliser prices by around 6.0 per cent, substantially undermining their competitive advantages over foreign producers. Notably, Lam Thao Fertilisers and Chemicals JSC said it losts around VND100 billion annually as a result of the VAT-free policy.

The Vietnam Fertiliser Association is urging the tax authority to subject fertlisers to VAT to help domestic producers stay cost-competitive.

Board IV is pressing for a new tax policy to lift firms out of their liquidity problems.

Under the policy, well-operating firms with good track records would be granted tax refunds first and subject to a tax review later to verify the amount. Meanwhile, the reversal would apply to newly-founded firms or those producing risky products. 

Bizhub





NEWS SAME CATEGORY

Gauging interest rate moves through expert lens

Interest rate movement has been abnormal in Vietnam in the past year. Peter Verhoeven, chairman of Prometheus Asia, shared with VIR’s Nhue Man his sentiments over...

Central bank pushes for rule alignments

The State Bank of Vietnam last week sought amendments and supplements to rules relating to the purchase of shares in Vietnamese credit institutions by foreign...

Insurance agencies to review processes, conduct: MoF

Insurance companies must tighten the supervision and inspection of insurance agencies, quality of consultation, and sales, said the Insurance Supervisory Authority...

Sustainable results to stem from collaborations

A number of Vietnamese lenders are seeking partnerships with international financial institutions for funding, particularly in sustainable development.

Vietnam’s non-life insurance market continues to lure foreign capital

Vietnam’s non-life insurance market has continued to attract foreign investors in the first months of this year.

Viet Nam’s non-life insurance market continues to lure foreign capital

Viet Nam’s non-life insurance market has continued to attract foreign investors in the first months of this year.

HCM City tax department warns of criminals impersonating officials

The city's Tax Department has warned taxpayers in HCM City to remain vigilant in light of reports of individuals impersonating tax agency officials to commit fraud.

MoF proposes VAT reduction to 8% to boost economy

The Ministry of Finance has recently put forward a proposal to the government to bring down value-added tax (VAT) from 10 per cent to 8 per cent for a number of...

Overnight interbank interest rate surges in week

The average overnight interbank interest rate surged on April 6 by 0.20-1.22 percentage points for all terms under one month to reach 4.47 per cent per year after...

Banks warn of resurgent SMS scams

Banks are warning their customers about phishing SMS scams that are once again on the rise.

Bank stocks

Insurance stocks


MOST READ


Back To Top